“Who would you like Charlie St. Cloud (Zac Efron) to choose – his brother or the girl he likes? And why?”

I think I would prefer Charlie St. Cloud to choose his brother as he's part of the family. Still no matter what family do come first before the girlfriend as he may not be together forever with the girlfriend. His brother would know him better than anyone, also closest to him. 

Catch Zac Efron in his new romantic movie Charlie St. Cloud, opening in cinemas September 30!